 I found this recipe several years ago in a Harvest Holiday Cookbook my Mom gave me from The Sidney Daily News in Sidney, OH. It was submitted by Mary Morrison. There is a restaurant in Sidney called The Spot to Eat which serves an amazing Old Fashion Cream Pie. I don't know if it is the same recipe or not, but it sure is good. When President Bush came through Sidney during his campaign, he made sure to stop at The Spot.
I make this recipe with my Aunt Carol's Never Fail Pie Crust. This recipe makes two pies so it is great for a crowd. It is really sweet and is especially good with whipped cream. See the recipe in Desserts and Decadence.
3 Comments
Ashley
1/10/2011 12:26:06 am
I made this over Christmas and LOVED it! It really tasted just like the spot! I live in maryland so it was nice to have something from back home! I came back to the site to get the recipe and its not showing up. Can you help me out? Thanks!
Michelle
9/20/2014 07:25:07 am
Where is the recipe for the old-fashioned cream pie? I'm not finding it. 9/20/2014 03:56:00 pm
I have reposted the recipe so now there is a direct link to it. Leave a Reply. |
Welcome to Home Ec @ HomeHi, I'm Faith, a former Family and Consumer Science teacher turned work at home Mom blogger. I love God, my family, and food. You can usually find me in the kitchen preparing family friendly, homemade recipes and taking lots of pictures.  
Most Popular Posts
Easy Weeknight Chicken Fajitas
Current Giveaways:
  
  |
RSS Feed